Sensitivity analysis allows him to determine what level of accuracy is necessary for a parameter to make the model sufficiently useful and valid. To facilitate the analysis of distributional data in a general experimental setting, we introduce a computational framework to ef. There are a number of questions that could be asked concerning the sensitivity of an optimal solution to changes in the data. A distributional analysis of adopting the fairtaxbhi 42507. In this paper we provide a general mathematical framework for distributional transforms, which allows for many examples that are used extensively in the lite. As such, there is an obvious connection with robust statistical methodology and outlier. Simulation analysis estimation of the distribution of different possible outcomes. Some sensitivity analysis tools are directed towards the impact of distributional andor modeling assumptions, whereas others refer to the impact one or a few subjects can have on the conclusions. First, the effects of forecast errors have been analyzed. Stochastic sensitivity analysis and kernel inference via. Distributional reinforcement learning with ensembles. An analysis of categorical distributional reinforcement. All the simulations have been conducted for a complete year using real data in order to obtain realistic results.
Instead of an additive shock to original loss, we apply a composition group of con. The distributional impact of public services in european. In this work we discuss a different kind of sensitivity analysisdistributional sensitiv ity analysis dsa, which is intended to quantify the impact on the qoi with respect to changes in the. Thus, this research develops an original method, referred to as distributional sensitivity analysis, that considers which factors would on average cause the greatest reduction in output variance, given that the portion of a particular factors variance that can be reduced is a random variable. The distributional impact of taxes and transfers the distributional impact of taxes and transfers. A distributional analysis of fiscal policies in the united. Grantham research institute on climate change and the environment and centre for climate change economics and policy, london school of economics and. In this paper probabilistic distributions for oil and gas resources are applied to derive a set of scenarios. This allowed to perform g sample size for the sensitivity analyses 1st level sa. For high values of the distributional sensitivity parameter. A tutorial miqdad asaria, msc, susan griffin, phd, richard cookson, phd distributional costeffectiveness analysis dcea is a framework for incorporating health inequality concerns into the economic evaluation of health sector interventions.
Exploring the sensitivity 2 2 exploring the sensitivity of horns parallel analysis to the distributional form of random data abstract horns parallel analysis pa is the method of consensus in the literature on empirical methods for. This handbook further develops the discussion of the principles on risk analysis that is contained in chapter xi uncertainty. Department of economics lynchburg college lynchburg, va. Sensitivity analysis using distributional data fig. The goal of this analysis is to evaluate the sensitivity of the energy projection according to these uncertainties. Therefore, a detailed analysis will be carried out on the impact of the resource estimates for conventional oil and gas. Mirror, mirror, on the wall, who in this land is fairest. Costbenefit analysis cba is the primary tool that economists em. Introduction efficient frontier techniques, including both stochastic frontier analysis sfa and data environment analysis dea, are widely used to identify high and low performing organizations. Project risk evaluation methods sensitivity analysis 35 as a result of previous experience from postevaluation studies and analysis of the project context, a preliminary set of likely key variables can be chosen on the following basis. Distributional assumptions and confounding assumptions. Sensitivity analysis provides an invaluable tool for addressing such issues. Sensitivity analysis can also indicate which parameter values are. An overview is given in molenberghs and kenward 2007.
It can be shown that this assumption is satisfied for an entire family of distributions even if both the measured covariates and the unmeasured confounder affect the exposure of interest. Sensitivity analysis analysis of the effects of changes in sales, costs, etc. Author links open overlay panel livia paleari a roberto confalonieri b. Different regulations may call for different emphases in the analysis, depending on the nature and complexity of the regulatory issues and the sensitivity of the benefit and cost estimates to the key assumptions. A new method for sensitivity analysis based on probability distortions is introduced in section 6. Given that the variance of factor i that may be reduced is a. Second, the benefits of participating in intraday markets have also been assessed. Pdf distributional transforms, probability distortions. Sensitivity analysis suppose that you have just completed a linear programming solution which will have a major impact on your company, such as determining how much to increase the overall production capacity, and are about to present the results to the board of directors. Chapter 6, appropriately discounted benefits and costs should be reported as well. Distributional transforms, probability distortions, and.
The stochastic sensitivity at a parameter value is defined as the divergence between distributions corresponding to that parameter value and one perturbation step apart in either direction defined by the user. Sensitivity analysis can be used to find switch points critical parameter values at which estimated net benefits change sign or the low cost alternative switches. In this case, assuming the variance of a given factor can be reduced to zero through further research leads to a different conclusion regarding which factors should be researched than distributional sensitivity analysis, which assumes the amount of variance that can be reduced for a given factor is a random variable. A framework for sensitivity analysis of decision trees. Sensitivity analysis is especially valuable when the information is lacking to carry out a formal probabilistic simulation.
Exploring the sensitivity of horns parallel analysis to. A key assumption for this is that a given factor can, through further research, be fixed to some point on its domain. Sensitivity and risk analysis of adbs guidelines for the economic analysis of projects 1997. The need for sensitivity tests somewhat undermines the claim that social. View enhanced pdf access article on wiley online library html view download pdf for offline viewing. A distributional analysis of fiscal policies in the united states, 20002012. Commentary open access a tutorial on sensitivity analyses. Among the uses for global sensitivity analysis is factor prioritization. In this chapter we will address those that can be answered most easily.
We are likely overlooking the impact of distributional assumptions. Scenario analysis project analysis given a particular combination of assumptions. Break even analysis analysis of the level of sales or other variable at which the. Spatiotemporal quantile regression for detecting distributional changes in environmental processes brian j reich department of statistics north carolina state university october 18, 2011 abstract climate change may lead to changes in several aspects of the distribution of climate variables. Figure b compares the main effect sensitivity indices estimated by global sensitivity analysis for each factor with the average adjusted main effect sensitivity indices estimated via distributional sensitivity analysis. Sensitivity analysis of efficiency rankings to distributional assumptions. Methodologies for computing the sensitivity index function for dsa are introduced in sec. Global sensitivity analysis and distributional sensitivity analysis are introduced in secs. This study provides an indepth discussion of the distribution of u.
Forecast error sensitivity analysis for bidding in. Chapter 5 the distributional impact of fiscal policy in indonesia 149 jon jellema, matthew waipoi, and rythia afkar. Conducting highquality analysis requires competent professional judgment. An analysis of categorical distributional reinforcement learning mark rowland1 marc g. Sensitivity of distributional effects, measured by expenditure per capita, to changes. If the tests reveal that the model is insensitive, then it may be possible to use an estimate rather than a value with greater precision. The global sensitivity results suggest that the ranking for factor prioritization be factor 2, 3, and then 1. Consider a policy that makes some individuals betteroff and no individuals worseoff. Pdf distributional sensitivity analysis researchgate. The purpose of this paper is to study the impact of including the value of public health care, longterm care, education and childcare on estimates of income inequality and financial poverty in 23 european countries. Distributional sensitivity analysis dsa instead treats the uncertainty reduction in the inputs as a random variable, and defines a variancebased sensitivity index function that characterizes. In this tutorial, we describe the technical details of. A comparison of the current tax system and the fairtax plan david g.
1017 171 83 562 676 797 1398 252 302 123 1244 1443 1335 733 730 1252 142 1377 61 1255 1498 784 201 633 1346 328 1368 333 1285 645 98 192 272 419 1162